Clinician reliability of eyelid and periorbital measurements in the oculoplastic assessment
Author: Yi Ting Yu
Base Hospital / Institution: Barts and The London Medical School, Queen Mary University of London
ePoster presentation
Abstract ID: 25-429
Purpose
To evaluate inter-clinician reliability amongst senior clinicians in eyelid and periorbital assessments in a busy oculoplastics clinic in a real-world setting. Findings will help enhance the accuracy and reproducibility of eyelid assessments.
Methods
116 patients were prospectively recruited at Moorfields Eye Hospital over a 3-month period. 5 clinicians participated in the study, with each patient assessed by 2 clinicians. Assessed manual oculoplastic measurements included palpebral aperture (PA), margin reflex distances (MRD1, MRD2), upper lid show (ULS), lower scleral show (LSS), skin crease height (SCH), levator function (LF), and canthal distances (IPD, ICD, OCD). Inter-clinician agreement was analysed with Bland-Altman plots.
Results
Bland-Altman analysis demonstrated variable inter-clinician agreement across eyelid measurements. MRD1 (-0.35 to 0.6mm), MRD2 (-0.51 to 0.33mm), LF (-0.36 to 0.08mm) and LSS (-0.09 to 0.15mm) showed strong agreement. In contrast, greater inter-clinician variability was observed for PA (–0.67 to 0.16 mm) and SCH (–1.80 to 1.28 mm), with the largest discrepancies seen in the horizontal facial measurements ICD (–2.18 to 1.15 mm) and OCD (–3.14 to 1.09 mm). Outliers beyond the 95% limits were observed across all parameters, highlighting discrepancies in clinician assessments.
Conclusion
Our findings demonstrate that inter-clinician variability depends on the specific eyelid measurement assessed. MRD1, MRD2, LF, and LSS showed strong inter-rater agreement, whereas greater variability was observed for other parameters, such as the horizontal facial measurements ICD and OCD. Outliers across all parameters highlight that inter-clinician variability is an inherent limitation in current practice for measuring eyelid parameters . These results underscore the need to investigate contributing factors and support the development of more standardised or automated tools to improve measurement consistency.
Additional Authors
| First name | Last name | Base Hospital / Institution |
|---|---|---|
| Laura | Ah-Kye | Moorfields Eye Hospital, London, United Kingdom |
| Yiu Wai | Chan | Moorfields Eye Hospital, London, United Kingdom |
| Nigel | Griffith | Moorfields Eye Hospital, London, United Kingdom |
| Katie | Myint | Moorfields Eye Hospital, London, United Kingdom |
| Allan | Ngheim | Moorfields Eye Hospital, London, United Kingdom |
| Amee | Patel | Moorfields Eye Hospital, London, United Kingdom |
| Swan | Kang | Moorfields Eye Hospital, London, United Kingdom |