Identification of upper eyelid asymmetry and the role of tarsal platform contour in conveying emotion
Author: Kelsey Roelofs
Base Hospital / Institution: Department of Ophthalmology and Visual Sciences, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
ePoster presentation
Abstract ID: 25-383
Purpose
Aesthetic goals of upper blepharoplasty and adjunctive techniques such as fat grafting include manipulation and control of tarsal platform show/contour, brow height and upper eyelid position. Moreover, prioritization of symmetry in one of these metrics over others may practically become necessary. Here, we characterize laypeople’s perception of symmetry and conveyed emotion in images depicting alterations of these key aesthetic components.
Methods
We employed a prospective psychometric evaluation via crowdsourcing. Layperson participants (n = 247) were surveyed via Amazon’s Mechanical Turk. Participants classified digitally drawn face images differing in either upper eyelid symmetry (MRD1, BFS, TPS, TPC) or tarsal platform contour (highest TPS medially, centrally, laterally). Primary outcomes were recognition of asymmetry and Ekman’s six basic emotions. Secondary outcome was time participants spent selecting an image.
Results
247 responses were collected. Significant asymmetry (84.2%, 69.6%; p<0.05) was correctly identified when the TPC was high medially and centrally, but not laterally. Participants were best at identifying asymmetry in MRD1 (91.9%) followed by TPS (66.8%). There was no significant difference in participant response when symmetry in BFS was altered.
With respect to emotion, the majority of participants identified a high central TPC as conveying surprise, and a high medial TPC produced equal amounts of fear and sadness. No pattern of emotion was identified for a high lateral TPC. Question response time was inversely correlated to % agreement for all groups. Overall, participants were in greater agreement and faster to report TPC asymmetry rather than MRD1/BFS/TPS asymmetry
Conclusion
We aimed to more precisely characterize the role of MRD1, TPS, BFS and TPC in perceptions of upper eyelid symmetry and conveyance of emotion. Laypersons were able to readily identify asymmetry in MRD1 and TPS but not BFS. High medial TPC conveys surprise, while high central TPC conveys fear and sadness. Further study evaluating standardized pre and post-operative patient photographs is required.
Additional Authors
| First name | Last name | Base Hospital / Institution |
|---|---|---|
| Adam | Wandzura | Department of Ophthalmology and Visual Sciences, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada |
| Stefania | Diniz | Department of Orbital and Ophthalmic Plastic Surgery, University of California, Los Angeles, California, USA |